System and method for restoring deleted objects and their assignments to other objects based on any deletion of the other objects

ABSTRACT

A system and method on one computer records actions on objects performed on a second computer. If an object is deleted from the second computer, the first computer can restore to a point in time the state of the object on the second computer, including assignments made between it and other objects, using the recorded actions.

CROSS REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS

This application is a continuation of U.S. patent application Ser. No.14/341,832 entitled “System and Method for Restoring Deleted Objects andTheir Assignments to Other Objects” filed by Huynh Hoang on Jul. 27,2014, which claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Patent ApplicationSer. No. 61/859,164 entitled, “Method and Apparatus for RestoringDeleted Objects and Their Assignments to Other Objects” filed by HuynhHoang on Jul. 26, 2013, each having the same assignee as the presentinvention and each is incorporated by reference in its entirety.

FIELD OF THE INVENTION

The present invention is related to computer software and morespecifically to computer software for restoration of deleted objects.

BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

Computer software may allow the user to define objects, assign attributevalues to keys of those objects (which may be predefined or defined bythe user), assign one object to one or more other objects, and deleteobjects. It can be desirable to operate such software in new ways.

SUMMARY OF INVENTION

A system and method on a first computer system receives from a secondcomputer system and records on the first computer system, indications ofactions performed on objects of the second computer system. The actionsmay include creation of an object, changes in attributes of an object,creation or deletion of an assignment of one or more objects to anotherobject, or deletion of an object.

The second computer system does not have the capability to restore adeleted object to the state it had at a point in time. A user may usethe first computer system to restore on the second computer system, tothe same state it had at a specified point in time, an object that hadbeen deleted from the second computer system. The first computer systemrestores the object to the point in time using the recorded actions.Communication between the first and second computer systems may be madevia an API.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

FIG. 1 is a block schematic diagram of a conventional computer system.

FIG. 2, is a flowchart illustrating a method of defining objects andtheir assignments, deleting objects, and restoring the state of objectsat a point in time according to one embodiment of the present invention.

FIG. 3 is a block schematic diagram of a system for defining objects andtheir assignments, deleting objects, and restoring the state of objectsat a point in time according to one embodiment of the present invention.

FIG. 4 is a block schematic diagram illustrating shadow system 330 ofFIG. 3 according to one embodiment of the present invention.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF A PREFERRED EMBODIMENT

The present invention may be implemented as computer software on aconventional computer system. Referring now to FIG. 1, a conventionalcomputer system 150 for practicing the present invention is shown.Processor 160 retrieves and executes software instructions stored instorage 162 such as memory, which may be Random Access Memory (RAM) andmay control other components to perform the present invention. Thecomponents of the system described herein may be implemented via one ormore hardware computer processors that operate under firmware orhardware control as described herein.

Storage 162 may be used to store program instructions or data or both.Storage 164, such as a computer disk drive or other nonvolatile storage,may provide storage of data or program instructions. In one embodiment,storage 164 provides longer term storage of instructions and data, withstorage 162 providing storage for data or instructions that may only berequired for a shorter time than that of storage 164. All storageelements described herein may include conventional memory and/or diskstorage and may include a conventional database.

Input device 166 such as a computer keyboard or mouse or both allowsuser input to the system 150. Output 168, such as a display or printer,allows the system to provide information such as instructions, data orother information to the user of the system 150. Storage input device170 such as a conventional floppy disk drive or CD-ROM drive accepts viainput 172 computer program products 174 such as a conventional floppydisk or CD-ROM or other nonvolatile storage media that may be used totransport computer instructions or data to the system 150. Computerprogram product 174 has encoded thereon computer readable program codedevices 176, such as magnetic charges in the case of a floppy disk oroptical encodings in the case of a CD-ROM which are encoded as programinstructions, data or both to configure the computer system 150 tooperate as described below.

In one embodiment, each computer system 150 is a conventional SUNMICROSYSTEMS T SERIES SERVER running the SOLARIS operating systemcommercially available from ORACLE CORPORATION of Redwood Shores,Calif., a PENTIUM-compatible personal computer system such as areavailable from DELL COMPUTER CORPORATION of Round Rock, Tex. running aversion of the WINDOWS operating system (such as XP, VISTA, or 7)commercially available from MICROSOFT Corporation of Redmond Wash. or aMacintosh computer system running the MACOS or OPENSTEP operating systemcommercially available from APPLE INCORPORATED of Cupertino, Calif. andthe FIREFOX browser commercially available from MOZILLA FOUNDATION ofMountain View, California or INTERNET EXPLORER browser commerciallyavailable from MICROSOFT above, although other systems may be used. Eachcomputer system 150 may be a SAMSUNG GALAXY NEXUS III commerciallyavailable from SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS GLOBAL of Seoul, Korea running theANDROID operating system commercially available from GOOGLE, INC. ofMountain View, Calif. Various computer systems may be employed, with thevarious computer systems communicating with one another via theInternet, a conventional cellular telephone network, an Ethernetnetwork, or all of these.

Referring now to FIG. 2, a method of performing actions on objects isshown according to one embodiment of the present invention. The presentinvention operates using two computer programs: one is referred to asthe base program, and the other is referred to as the shadow program.

An action is received at the base program or the shadow program 210. Inone embodiment, the base program may be used to receive actions thatcreate objects, assign or adding attributes of objects, assign oneobject to another object, or delete an object. The shadow program may beused to receive actions that restore deletions on the base program to apoint in time. In one embodiment, the shadow program is a computerprogram that is separate from the base program, and that receives datafrom the base program and can control the base program for example viaan API. In one embodiment, these two programs are distributed bycompanies that are independent from one another, i.e. one company doesnot control the other and vice versa.

In one embodiment, objects describe sets of one or more skills, peoplewho have those skills, and tasks requiring such skills. Attributes arecomponents of objects, such as individual skills in a set of skillscorresponding to an object.

Any number of actions may be performed on the same object, and there maybe any number of objects on which the actions are performed. Thus, themethod of FIG. 2 may be iterated any number of times, on multipleobjects using all of the actions described.

If the action is an indication to create an object 212, the object iscreated and stored on the base program. In one embodiment, each objecthas at least one attribute, which may be supplied as part of the actionof creating the object, and such attributes are stored by the programsthat receive them, associated with the object to which they correspond.As described below, attributes of objects may be modified or added. Inone embodiment, attribute values are associated with keys that definewhat the attribute is, and such keys may be predefined or defined by theuser. When attribute values are received, they are received with theirkeys or an indication of the key to which that attribute valuecorresponds. In one embodiment, attribute values may include the name orother identifier of the object and other information. If the user doesnot define attribute values for some or all keys, default values may beassigned. In one embodiment, all objects described herein areidentifiable by an identifier of the object. The method continues atstep 232.

At step 232, the base program outputs an indication of the action, theobject identifier or identifiers, and any new or changed attributevalues via the API. The shadow program receives the action indicationand attribute values and stores 234 them internally, with the date andtime they were received. In one embodiment, any attributes output andreceived include the identifier of the object to which the attributebelongs, and the action. The method continues at step 210. Any number ofactions may be received via step 210. When an action is received, aniteration of steps 232 and 234 are performed as described herein.

If the action is an indication to modify attributes of an object 212,the identifier of the object whose attributes should be modified and thevalue of the attributes are received as part of step 210, such attributevalues are substituted for any prior attribute values 222, and themethod continues at step 232, where the object identifier and attributevalues and keys for which the attribute values correspond are reported,and received, time stamped and stored by the shadow program at step 234.Deletion of attribute values may be performed by modifying an attributewith an empty or null value. Although one object is described herein,the action may be used to modify attributes of multiple objects, inwhich case the report of the action that is provided, received andstored includes the identifiers of the objects or a means of identifyingthem, such as a range of identifiers.

If the action is to assign an object to one or more other objects orremove such assignment 212, the identifiers of the objects and anindication of the assignment or assignments to be made are received aspart of step 210, the program makes and stores such assignments orremoval 224 and the method continues at step 232, where the indicationof the assignment or removal, and the object identifiers involved areoutput by the base program, and received, time stamped and stored by theshadow program at step 234. An assignment may be modified by deletingthe current assignment and making the new assignment. The methodcontinues at step 210 following step 234 in one embodiment, in anotherembodiment, the method continues at step 210 following step 232.

If the action is to delete an object, the identifier of the object isreceived as part of step 210, the program deletes the object 226, and ifthe object being deleted was assigned to another object, or if any otherobject was assigned to the object being deleted 228, any assignmentsmade to that object, and/or any assignments of the object made toanother object are deleted 230. Steps 228 and 230 may be performed ineither order. The method continues at step 232, where the identifier ofthe object, and any assignments that were deleted, are reported by thebase program, and received and stored by the shadow program 234, alongwith the time stamp. The method continues at step 210.

If the action is to restore a deleted object 212, the object identifierand restoration date and time to which the object should be restored isreceived as part of step 210, and the method continues at step 240. Inone embodiment if no date and time is specified, the date and time justprior to the time the object was most recently deleted is used as thedate and time. In one embodiment, an action to restore a deleted objectis received on the shadow program, while other actions may be receivedon either or both programs, or the base program.

In one embodiment, the user indicates as part of the action whether theassignment status of a restored object should also be restored and inwhich direction or directions: to the deleted object, from the deletedobject, or both. In one embodiment, restoration of assignments in bothdirections is the default for this action.

At step 240, the API is used on the shadow to create a new object on thebase program using the identifier of the deleted object, or anidentifier corresponding to such identifier. The information stored forthat object at the shadow program under one or more iterations of step234 is used to identify the state of the attributes as of the receiveddate and time 242, and the shadow program uses the API to set the valuesof the attributes of the newly created object to that state 244. Theinformation stored in the shadow program under one or more iterations ofstep 234 is used to identify the status of assignments of other objectsto the object, and/or of the object to other objects, (optionallycorresponding to the direction or directions of assignments indicated bythe user as described above) as of the date and time received 246, andthe shadow program uses the API to make such assignments to or of thenewly created object on the base program so that the state of the objectand assignments as of the date and time is restored. The methodcontinues at step 210.

In one embodiment, step 246 includes identifying objects that were partof an assignment with the specified object that have been deleted afterthe assignment to them was made and that were not restored to a point intime after that time but before the date and time specified by the user,and excluding them from the assignments made with the new object, asdescribed in more detail below. In another embodiment, all other objectsdeleted after the assignment was made are ignored when restoringassignments with the specified object, in yet another embodiment, anyother object deleted after the specified date and time is restored, andin still another embodiment, the user may select which, if any otherobjects are ignored or restored.

Referring now to FIG. 3, a system for restoring objects and theirassignments is shown according to one embodiment of the presentinvention. User devices 310 may include conventional personal computers,or smart devices such as tablets or smart phones and are used by usersto interact with the base system 320, the shadow system 330, or both vianetwork 340. Network 340 includes a conventional Ethernet network, theInternet, or both. Base system 320 may include a conventional personalcomputer or server computer operating the base program as describedabove. Base system 320 does not have the capability to restore deletedobjects and/or their assignments to one another. Shadow system 330 mayinclude a conventional personal computer or server computer operatingthe shadow program as described above. Base system 320 and shadow system330 communicate via network 340 and are different computer systems,physically separate from one another.

A user may use base system 320 to perform the create, modify attribute,assign one object to one or more other object, or delete actions asdescribed above. In such event, base system 320 performs such action andinternally stores the result. Additionally, base system 320 reports theaction to the shadow system via the API described above.

In one embodiment, a user may use shadow system 330 to perform theactions described herein. FIG. 4 shows shadow system 330 according toone embodiment of the present invention. Shadow system 330 includescommunication interface 410, coupled to network 340 via input/output408. Communication interface 410 includes a conventional communicationinterface capable of communicating via Ethernet, TCP/IP and othercommunication protocols. The user may provide indications of the create,modify attribute, assign one object to one or more other object, ordelete actions to a user interface provided by user interface manager422, which receives indications of them and forwards them to base system320 via the API. Base system 320 performs such action and internallystores the result, and reports the action to shadow system 330 via theAPI, as described above. Each action may be received with the otherinformation described above, and if any such action is received by userinterface manager 422, it also forwards such other information to basesystem 320 with the indication of the action.

Reported information receiver 412 receives the reported information fromthe base system 320 via the API, requests the current date and time fromoperating system 414, and stores the reported information (including anindication of the action, one or more object identifiers, attribute keysand values, assignment information including direction of the assignmentand whether the assignment is being deleted or added, and the currentdate and time in reported information storage 420. Reported informationstorage 420 includes conventional electronic disk or memory storage andmay include a conventional database.

The user may use the user interface provided by user interface manager422 to request restoration of a deleted object and its assignments, ifany, and supply an identifier, such as the name of the object, and thedate and time to which such object should be restored. In oneembodiment, the user may specify if assignments are to be restored withthe object and in which direction or directions: to the specifiedobject, from the specified object or in both directions. User interfacemanager 422 receives such information and builds a restoration objectthat includes such information and provides the restoration object toattribute status manager 424. Other restoration specifications may bereceived, included in the restoration object, and used as describedabove.

When it receives the restoration object, attribute status manager 424uses the information in reported information storage 420 and the objectinformation in the restoration object to identify the former status ofthe attributes, including keys and/or values, of the object specified bythe restoration object as of the date and time in the restorationobject. In one embodiment, attribute status manager 424 isolates, andorders by date and time, the information in reported information storagethat corresponds to the creation of the object and to changes ofattributes of the object referred to by the restoration object,identifies the initial attribute status on creation of the objectspecified, and applies changes made to attributes of such object in theorder in which such changes were recorded by their date and time. Forexample, as attribute values are changed or deleted, attribute statusmanager 424 also makes such changes and deletions in the order in whichthey were recorded. Attribute status manager 424 stores such keys,and/or values of each of the attributes into the restoration object, andprovides the restoration object to assignment status manager 426. In oneembodiment, if no date and time is specified in the restoration object,attribute status manager identifies the most recent deletion of theobject corresponding to the object identifier in the restoration object,uses the time immediately preceding such date and time as the date andtime to which the restoration should be made, and stores such date andtime in the restoration object.

When it receives the restoration object, assignment status manager 426isolates assignment information in reported information storage 420corresponding to the object identified in the restoration object, ordersby date and time recorded, and applies assignments made to or from suchobject to a table of assignments in the order in which they wererecorded. Each row in the table of assignments indicates the directionof the assignment, and the identifier of the other object correspondingto such assignment. If one or more assignments is made as indicated bythe recorded actions in reported information storage 420, assignmentstatus manager 426 makes the assignment in the table of assignmentsusing as many rows as needed. If one or more assignments is deleted asindicated by the recorded actions in reported information storage 420,assignment status manager 426 deletes the corresponding assignment inthe table of assignments. In one embodiment, assignment manager 426checks the directions of the assignments to be restored, and if noassignments are to be restored in either direction, it does not performthe isolating and ordering or assignment actions described above. Ifassignments in only one direction are to be restored, assignment statusmanager 426 only isolates and orders in reported information storage 420assignments corresponding to that direction.

In one embodiment, before it makes an assignment between the objectspecified in the assignment and another object, assignment statusmanager 426 checks reported information storage 420 to identify whetherthe other object was deleted subsequent to its assignment to or from theobject of the restoration object after the date and time the assignmentwas originally made, and if so, it does not add the corresponding entryfor such other object in the table of assignments, unless the otherobject was restored to a point in time as of before or at the date andtime of the restoration object being restored. Other embodiments may useother rules for omitting a restoration of an assignment. The other rulesfor restoration specified above may be used by assignment statusmanager, optionally as indicated in the restoration object.

Assignment status manager 426 adds the table of assignments to therestoration object and provides the restoration object to restorationmanager 428.

When it receives the restoration object, restoration manager 428 usesthe API to cause the base system 320 to create an object with the nameor other identifier of the object that was initially added to therestoration object, optionally using the attribute keys and valuesstored in the restoration object as the attribute keys and values to beassigned to the object upon creation. If not so initially assigned,restoration manager 428 may use the API to cause the base system 320assign the attribute values after the object is created. Restorationmanager 428 uses the table of assignments, if any, to cause the basesystem to assign the object initially added to the restoration object tothe other objects or assign the other objects to such object asindicated by the table of assignments so as to restore to the indicateddate and time the assignment status to or from the object restored, tothe extent indicated by the user.

Restoration manager 428 stores the identifier of the object initiallyadded to the restoration object, the date and time specified in therestoration object, and an indication that the object was restored, toreported information storage 420, for use as described above.

In the event that other objects deleted are restored as described above,restoration manager 428 may use conventional recursion techniques torestore such objects by duplicating the information received from theuser in a new restoration object, changing the object identifier to anobject identifier which should be restored, and providing the object toattribute status manager to initiate the restoration process of theother object as described above, optionally repeatedly, until all suchrestorations are completed.

SUMMARY

There is shown a method of restoring an object to a first point in time,including: receiving at a first computer program, an indication of eachof several actions taken or to be taken on a second computer program, onwhich the object resides or will reside, that does not have a capabilityto restore an object to a specified point in time, and that can becontrolled by the first computer program, the several actions comprisingmaking an association of the object with each of at least one differentobject; storing by the first computer program, information from the eachof the several indications received, and for each such indication, adate and a time corresponding to a time approximately when the actionscorresponding to the indications were taken; receiving at the firstcomputer program a command to restore the object to a particular pointin time, the command comprising an identifier of the object, anindication of the point in time, and an indication as to whether anyassociations to or from the object should be restored; and responsive tothe identifier of the object in the command, the information from theseveral indications stored by the first computer system, the date andtime of each of the several indications, and the point in time,providing from the first computer program to the second computerprogram, at least one command to take a set of at least one actioncausing the object to be restored as it existed on the second computerprogram at approximately the particular point in time except for anyassociations of that object at the point in time, and with at least oneassociations existing between the object and the at least one differentobject at the point in time additionally restored by the set of at leastone command responsive to the indication of the command received.

The method includes optional features whereby: the indication as towhether any associations to or from the object should be restoredcomprises an indication that any associations to, but not from theobject should be restored; the at least one association existing betweenthe object and the at least one different object at the point in timethat is additionally restored comprise at least one association with theat least one different object to, but not from, the object; and at leastone association existing from the object to the at least one differentobject at the point in time is not restored responsive to the command.

The method includes optional features whereby: the indication as towhether any associations to or from the object should be restoredcomprises an indication that any associations from, but not to theobject should be restored; the at least one association existing betweenthe object and the at least one different object at the point in timethat is additionally restored comprise at least one association from,but not to, the object; and at least one association existing to theobject from the at least one different object at the point in time isnot restored responsive to the command.

The method includes optional features whereby the first computer programand second computer program communicate via an applications programminginterface of the second computer program.

The method includes optional features whereby the particular point intime is inferred from an action that had been performed on the object.

The method includes optional features including not restoring at leastone association made between the object and at least one of the at leastone different object that was deleted after the association was made andwere not restored to an additional point in time after the assignmentwas made and before the point in time, where said at least oneassociation corresponds to the indication in the command.

There is shown a system for restoring an object to a first point intime, including: a reported information receiver having an input coupledto a computer program for receiving from the computer program anindication for each of several actions taken or to be taken on thecomputer program, on which the object resides or will reside, that doesnot have a capability to restore an object to a specified point in time,and that can be controlled by the first computer program, the severalactions comprising making an association of the object with each of atleast one different object, the reported information receiver forstoring via an output, information from the each of the severalindications received, and for each such indication, a date and a timecorresponding to a time approximately when the actions corresponding tothe indications were taken; a user interface manager having an input forreceiving a command to restore the object to a particular point in time,the command indicating the point in time and having an indication as towhether any associations to or from the object should be restored, theuser interface manager for providing at an output an identifier of theobject, the point in time and the indication as to whether anyassociations to or from the object should be restored; an attributestatus manager having an input coupled to the user interface manageroutput for receiving the identifier of the object and the point in time,and coupled to the reported information receiver output for receivingthe information from each of at least some of the several indications,and the dates and times of said indications, the attribute statusmanager for, responsive to the identifier of the object in the command,the information from the at least some of the several indicationsreceived at the attribute status manager input, the date and time of theat least some of the several indications, and the point in time,identifying at an output at least one attribute of the object as itexisted at the point in time, and providing at the attribute statusmanager output the identifier of the object; an assignment statusmanager having an input coupled to the user interface manager output forreceiving the identifier of the object, the point in time and theindication as to whether any associations to or from the object shouldbe restored, and coupled to the reported information receiver output forreceiving the information from each of at least some of the severalindications and the dates and times of said indications, the attributestatus manager for, responsive to the identifier of the object in thecommand, the information from the at least some of the severalindications received at the attribute status manager input, the date andtime of the at least some of the several indications, the point in time,and the indication as to whether any associations to or from the objectshould be restored, identifying at an output at least one indication ofassociation of the object as it existed at the point in time thatcorresponds to the indication as to whether any associations to or fromthe object should be restored; and a restoration manager having an inputcoupled to the attribute status manager output for receiving the atleast one attribute of the object as it existed at the point in time andthe identifier of the object; and to the assignment status manageroutput for receiving the at least one indication of the at least oneassociation of the object as it existed at the point in time thatcorresponds to the indication as to whether any associations to or fromthe object should be restored, the restoration manager for providing atan output coupled to the computer program, at least one command to takea set of at least one action causing the object to be restored as itexisted on the computer program at approximately the particular point intime except for any associations of that object at the point in time,and with associations existing between the object and the at least onedifferent object at the point in time additionally restored by said atleast one command responsive to the indication of the command,responsive to the attributes of the object as it existed at the point intime and the at least one indication of associations of the object as itexisted at the point in time that correspond to the indication as towhether any associations to or from the object should be restored.

The system includes optional features whereby: the indication as towhether any associations to or from the object should be restoredcomprises an indication that any associations to, but not from theobject should be restored; and the at least one association thatassignment status manager identifies at the assignment status manageroutput comprises at least one association to the object and from the atleast one different object that existed at the point in time but not atleast one association that existed from the object and to the at leastone different object at the point in time.

The system includes optional features whereby: the indication as towhether any associations to or from the object should be restoredcomprises an indication that any associations from, but not to theobject should be restored; the at least one association that assignmentstatus manager identifies at the assignment status manager outputcomprises at least one association from the object and to the at leastone different object that existed at the point in time but not at leastone association that existed to the object and from the at least onedifferent object at the point in time.

The system includes optional features whereby the restoration managerand the computer program communicate via an applications programminginterface of the second computer program.

The system includes optional features whereby the particular point intime is inferred from an action that had been performed on the object.

The system includes optional features whereby the assignment statusmanager does not provide at the assignment status manager output atleast one indication of at least one association made with at least oneof the at least one different object that was deleted after theassociation was made and was not restored to an additional point in timeafter the assignment was made and before the point in time, where saidat least one association not provided corresponds to the indication inthe command.

There is shown a computer program product comprising a computer useablemedium having computer readable program code embodied therein forrestoring an object to a first point in time, the computer programproduct including computer readable program code devices configured tocause a computer system to: receive at a first computer program, anindication of each of several actions taken or to be taken on a secondcomputer program, on which the object resides or will reside, that doesnot have a capability to restore an object to a specified point in time,and that can be controlled by the first computer program, the severalactions comprising making an association of the object with each of atleast one different object; store by the first computer program,information from the each of the several indications received, and foreach such indication, a date and a time corresponding to a timeapproximately when the actions corresponding to the indications weretaken; receive at the first computer program a command to restore theobject to a particular point in time, the command comprising anidentifier of the object, an indication of the point in time, and anindication as to whether any associations to or from the object shouldbe restored; and responsive to the identifier of the object in thecommand, the information from the several indications stored by thefirst computer system, the date and time of each of the severalindications, and the point in time, provide from the first computerprogram to the second computer program, at least one command to take aset of at least one action causing the object to be restored as itexisted on the second computer program at approximately the particularpoint in time except for any associations of that object at the point intime, and with at least one associations existing between the object andthe at least one different object at the point in time additionallyrestored by the set of at least one command responsive to the indicationof the command received.

The computer program product includes optional features whereby: theindication as to whether any associations to or from the object shouldbe restored comprises an indication that any associations to, but notfrom the object should be restored; the at least one associationexisting between the object and the at least one different object at thepoint in time that is additionally restored comprise at least oneassociation with the at least one different object to, but not from, theobject; and at least one association existing from the object to the atleast one different object at the point in time is not restoredresponsive to the command.

The computer program product includes optional features whereby: theindication as to whether any associations to or from the object shouldbe restored comprises an indication that any associations from, but notto the object should be restored; the at least one association existingbetween the object and the at least one different object at the point intime that is additionally restored comprise at least one associationfrom, but not to, the object; and at least one association existing tothe object from the at least one different object at the point in timeis not restored responsive to the command.

The computer program product includes optional features whereby thefirst computer program and second computer program communicate via anapplications programming interface of the second computer program.

The computer program product includes optional features whereby theparticular point in time is inferred from an action that had beenperformed on the object.

The computer program product optionally additional includes computerreadable program code devices configured to cause the computer system tonot restore at least one association made between the object and atleast one of the at least one different object that was deleted afterthe association was made and were not restored to an additional point intime after the assignment was made and before the point in time, wheresaid at least one association corresponds to the indication in thecommand.

What is claimed is:
 1. A method of restoring an object to a first pointin time, comprising: receiving at a first computer program, anindication of each of a plurality of actions taken or to be taken on asecond computer program, on which the object resides or will reside,that does not have a capability to restore the object to a specifiedpoint in time, and that can be controlled by the first computer program,the plurality of actions comprising making an association of the objectwith each of at least one different object; storing by the firstcomputer program, information from the each of the plurality ofindications received, and for each such indication, a date and a timecorresponding to a time approximately when the action corresponding tothe indication was taken; receiving at the first computer program acommand to restore the object to a particular point in time, the commandcomprising an identifier of the object, an indication of the point intime, and an indication as to whether any associations to or from theobject should be restored; and responsive to the command received, usingthe identifier of the object in the command, the information from theplurality of indications stored by the first computer system, the dateand time of each of the plurality of indications, and the point in time,to provide from the first computer program to the second computerprogram, at least one command to take a set of at least one actioncausing the object to be incorporated into the second computer programas it existed on the second computer program at approximately theparticular point in time except for any associations of that object atthe point in time, and with at least one association existing betweenthe object and the at least one different object at the point in timeadditionally incorporated into the second computer program using the setof at least one command, responsive to the indication of the commandreceived, and at least one of the plurality of indications of an actioncomprising deleting the object, at least one of the at least oneindications having a stored date and time after the point in time. 2.The method of claim 1, wherein the at least one association existingbetween the object and the at least one different object at the point intime is incorporated in to the second computer program additionallyresponsive to an incorporation into the second computer program of theat least one different object directed by the first computer program. 3.The method of claim 2 wherein the at least one association existingbetween the object and the at least one different object at the point intime is incorporated in to the second computer program additionallyresponsive to a different point in time corresponding to theincorporation.
 4. The method of claim 3 wherein the at least oneassociation existing between the object and the at least one differentobject at the point in time is incorporated in to the second computerprogram additionally responsive to the different point in time of theincorporation being on or before the point in time.
 5. A system forrestoring an object to a first point in time, comprising: a reportedinformation receiver having an input coupled to a computer program forreceiving from the computer program an indication for each of aplurality of actions taken or to be taken on the computer program, onwhich the object resides or will reside, that does not have a capabilityto restore the object to a specified point in time, and that can becontrolled by the system, the plurality of actions comprising making anassociation of the object with each of at least one different object,the reported information receiver for storing via an output, informationfrom the each of the plurality of indications received, and for eachsuch indication, a date and a time corresponding to a time approximatelywhen the action corresponding to the indication was taken; a userinterface manager having an input for receiving a command to restore theobject to a particular point in time, the command indicating the pointin time and having an indication as to whether any associations to orfrom the object should be restored, the user interface manager forproviding at an output an identifier of the object, the point in timeand the indication as to whether any associations to or from the objectshould be restored; an attribute status manager having an input coupledto the user interface manager output for receiving the identifier of theobject and the point in time, and coupled to the reported informationreceiver output for receiving the information from each of at least someof the plurality of indications, and the dates and times of saidindications, the attribute status manager for, using the identifier ofthe object in the command, the information from the at least some of theplurality of indications received at the attribute status manager input,the date and time of the at least some of the plurality of indications,and the point in time, to identify at an output at least one attributeof the object as it existed at the point in time, and providing at theattribute status manager output the identifier of the object; anassignment status manager having an input coupled to the user interfacemanager output for receiving the identifier of the object, the point intime and the indication as to whether any associations to or from theobject should be restored, and coupled to the reported informationreceiver output for receiving the information from each of at least someof the plurality of indications and the dates and times of saidindications, the assignment status manager for, responsive to receipt ofthe identifier of the object, the information from the at least some ofthe plurality of indications received at the assignment status managerinput, the date and time of the at least some of the plurality ofindications, the point in time, and the indication as to whether anyassociations to or from the object should be restored, identifying at anoutput at least one indication of association of the object as itexisted at the point in time that corresponds to the indication as towhether any associations to or from the object should be restored,excluding associations of one or more objects that were deleted afterthe point in time as indicated by the information from each of at leastsome of the plurality of indications; and a restoration manager havingan input coupled to the attribute status manager output for receivingthe at least one attribute of the object as it existed at the point intime and the identifier of the object; and to the assignment statusmanager output for receiving the at least one indication of the at leastone association of the object as it existed at the point in time thatcorresponds to the indication as to whether any associations to or fromthe object should be restored, the restoration manager for providing atan output coupled to the computer program, at least one command to takea set of at least one action causing the object to be incorporated intothe second computer program as it existed on the computer program atapproximately the particular point in time except for any associationsof that object at the point in time, and with associations existingbetween the object and the at least one different object at the point intime additionally incorporated into the second computer program by saidat least one command responsive to the indication of the command,responsive to the attributes of the object as it existed at the point intime and the at least one indication of associations of the object as itexisted at the point in time that correspond to the indication as towhether any associations to or from the object should be restored. 6.The system of claim 5, wherein the assignment status manager excludesthe one or more associations additionally responsive to an incorporationinto the second computer program of the at least one different objectdirected by the first computer program.
 7. The system of claim 6,wherein the assignment status manager excludes the one or moreassociations additionally responsive to a different point in timecorresponding to the incorporation.
 8. The system of claim 7, whereinthe assignment status manager excludes the one or more associationsadditionally responsive to the different point in time of theincorporation being on or before the point in time.
 9. A computerprogram product comprising a nontransitory computer useable mediumhaving computer readable program code embodied therein for restoring anobject to a first point in time, the computer program product comprisingcomputer readable program code devices configured to cause a computersystem to: receive at a first computer program, an indication of each ofa plurality of actions taken or to be taken on a second computerprogram, on which the object resides or will reside, that does not havea capability to restore an object to a specified point in time, and thatcan be controlled by the first computer program, the plurality ofactions comprising making an association of the object with each of atleast one different object; store by the first computer program,information from the each of the plurality of indications received, andfor each such indication, a date and a time corresponding to a timeapproximately when the action corresponding to the indication was taken;receive at the first computer program a command to restore the object toa particular point in time, the command comprising an identifier of theobject, an indication of the point in time, and an indication as towhether any associations to or from the object should be restored; andresponsive to the command received, use the identifier of the object inthe command, the information from the plurality of indications stored bythe first computer system, the date and time of each of the plurality ofindications, and the point in time, to provide from the first computerprogram to the second computer program, at least one command to take aset of at least one action causing the object to be incorporated intothe second computer program as it existed on the second computer programat approximately the particular point in time except for anyassociations of that object at the point in time, and with at least oneassociation existing between the object and the at least one differentobject at the point in time additionally incorporated into the secondcomputer program using the set of at least one command, responsive tothe indication of the command received, and at least one of theplurality of indications of an action comprising deleting the object, atleast one of the at least one indications having a stored date and timeafter the point in time.
 10. The computer program product of claim 9,wherein the at least one association existing between the object and theat least one different object at the point in time is incorporated in tothe second computer program additionally responsive to an incorporationinto the second computer program of the at least one different objectdirected by the first computer program.
 11. The computer program productof claim 10, wherein the at least one association existing between theobject and the at least one different object at the point in time isincorporated in to the second computer program additionally responsiveto a different point in time corresponding to the incorporation.
 12. Thecomputer program product of claim 11, wherein the at least oneassociation existing between the object and the at least one differentobject at the point in time is incorporated in to the second computerprogram additionally responsive to the different point in time of theincorporation being on or before the point in time.